Harvard Report Compares NFL’s Health Policies and Practices to Those of Other Professional Sports Leagues
While the NFL’s player health policies and practices are robust in some areas, there are opportunities for improvement in others, according to the findings of a newly released report by researchers at The Petrie-Flom Center at Harvard Law School.
The report, published today, is the first comprehensive comparative analysis of health policies and practices across professional sports leagues. The research is part of the ongoing Football Players Health Study at Harvard University.
The analysis compares the NFL’s player health policies, including those related to club medical personnel and conflicts of interest, injury rates and policies (such as detailed statistics regarding concussion and other injuries), health-related benefits, drug and performance-enhancing substance policies and compensation and eligibility rules, with those of Major League Baseball, the National Basketball Association, the National Hockey League, Major League Soccer and the Canadian Football League.
Acknowledging important differences among these sports, the authors of the report conclude that there are some notable disparities in best practices when it comes to common issues related to player health and wellbeing that may not necessarily be sport-specific. The findings, the authors say, underscore opportunities for these organizations to learn from one another in light of their shared interest in player health.
“In many respects the leagues and their games are very different as we acknowledge in the report,” said I. Glenn Cohen, Professor of Law at Harvard Law School and Co-Lead of the Law and Ethics Initiative of the Football Players Health Study at Harvard University. “Nonetheless, they face some common issues where they have the opportunity to learn from one another given their shared interest in player health.”
Specifically, the report reveals variations in healthcare policies and practices between the NFL and other leagues. Some of these variations include:
- Preseason physicals performed by a neutral physician
- Concussion-specific short-term injury list
- Injury reporting policies that do not require disclosing the location of a player’s injury
- Providing lifelong health insurance to former players
- Allowing players to be vested in pension plans on their first day in the league
- Providing treatment for players who violated performance-enhancing substance policies
Details are described in the Executive Summary of the report.
The research was conducted as part of the Law and Ethics Initiative of the Football Players Health Study at Harvard University. The research is independent and not directed by the NFL, NFLPA or any other stakeholder. The report’s content, findings and conclusions are solely the responsibility of the authors, and do not represent the official views of the NFLPA, the Football Players Health Study at Harvard University or Harvard University. These entities exercise no control over the findings or recommendations.
For more information on the report and the Law and Ethics Initiative, please see the Frequently Asked Questions from the report.
Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics at Harvard Law School
The Petrie-Flom Center for Health Law Policy, Biotechnology, and Bioethics at Harvard Law School is a research program devoted to interdisciplinary analysis and legal scholarship in these fields. The Center’s work involves public engagement, academic programs, sponsored research and independent scholarship.
Football Players Health Study at Harvard University
Launched in 2014, the Football Players Health Study at Harvard University is composed of select studies and research initiatives addressing the whole player over the course of his entire life. The study is funded pursuant to an agreement with the NFLPA, and utilizes shared resources across supporting institutions at Harvard University.
For more information: Gina Vild, Harvard Medical School, 617.432.0440
- Rapid Response: Why CTE Prevalence Estimates in Former NFL Players May Be Inflated
- Bringing Insights Home to Alumni
- Study Shows Rise in Suicide Rate Among NFL Players
- Behind the Helmet: Caring for the Families Who Care for NFL Players
- Our Approach to TBI & Neurodegenerative Disease
- Osteoarthritis and Former NFL Players
- For Former NFL Players, Football Before Age 12 Not Linked to Worse Health Later in Life: Study
- Playing Football At Younger Ages Not Linked With Poor Health Outcomes
- Offensive and Defensive Strategies for Men’s Health Webinar – September 26, 2023
- Examining Race Trends in the NFL: Diversity, but not Inclusion
- Research Spotlight: New Research Suggests PET Test for Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy Has Limited Value
- Unexpected Finding: In-Person Assessment Study of Former NFL Players Leads to Treatable Neurological Condition
- Football Players Health Study Enters Next Phase
- Concussions and Cognitive Performance
- Our Gratitude to James D. (Jim) McFarland: 1947-2020
- After the Game Is Over
- Research Huddle Podcast: The Brain Health Study
- Meet the Doc – Ross Zafonte, DO
- Moving forward: Minimally-Invasive ACL Repair
- Building a Better Knee Brace for NFL Players
- Advancing Research on Potential Treatment for TBI
- Preliminary Results Infographic: Exercise and Weight Gain
- In-Person Assessments: Visits to Boston Hospitals for Testing, Scans, and Other Evaluations
- Epidemiology: Study of Patterns within a Population
- Targeted Studies: Prevention, Diagnostics, and Interventions Developed by Researchers, and Innovative Approaches to Testing Players Remotely
- Preliminary Results Infographic: Positions, Conditions, and Quality of Life
- More Preliminary Results from the First Health Questionnaire
- Preliminary Results from the First Health Questionnaire
- Researchers at the University of Houston Law Center and Harvard Law School Address Legal Issues in Evaluating NFL Player Health and Performance
- Innovation Challenge – Chronic Pain
- Innovation Challenge – Sleep Apnea
- Job Posting: Postdoctoral Research Fellow
- Bridge-Enhanced ACL Repair (BEAR) Technique
- Harvard Launches ResearchKit App to Support Football Player Health
- Our Gratitude to Willie Richardson: 1939-2016
- A Visit with Former Players: Pre-Super Bowl 50 Trip
- Talks@12: Tackling Football Injuries
- Milestone: Over 2,570 Former Players Participate in our Study
- Widening the Field
- Study finds sleep apnea may be widespread — and often underdiagnosed or undertreated — among former professional football players
- NFL Spouses and Partners Face High Levels of Caregiver Burden, Anxiety, and Depression
- Study of Former NFL Players Finds 1 in 3 Believe They Have CTE
- Study of Former NFL Players Reveals Racial Disparities in Chronic Pain
- Case report: Former Football Player’s Cognitive Symptoms Improved after Study Revealed Alternative Diagnosis and Treatment
- For Former Football Players, Concussion and Hypertension Go Hand in Hand, New Study Shows
- Do Former Football Players Age Faster?
- Study Points to Health Disparities Among Former NFL Players
- Inappropriate Diagnoses
- Number of Years in NFL, Certain Positions Portend Greater Risk for Cognitive, Mental Health Problems in Former Players
- Concussions Linked to Erectile Dysfunction in Former NFL Players
- Can Relationships and Personal Networks Impact the Health of Former Pro Football Players?
- Study Hints at Elevated Cardiac Risk Among Former Football Players with ACL Tears
- Listening to NFL Players: On Mental Health
- New Article Examines the Possibility of Applying Workplace Safety Rules to the NFL
- Harvard Report Compares NFL’s Health Policies and Practices to Those of Other Professional Sports Leagues
- Recommendations to Improve NFL Player Health
- Scientists Develop Antibody to Treat Traumatic Brain Injury and Prevent Long-Term Neurodegeneration
- CTE in NFL Players: What a New Study Tells Us — And What It Doesn’t
- When CTE Fears Keep Former Football Players From Addressing Treatable Conditions
- Brain Disease Is Pervasive in N.F.L., New Estimate Suggests
- Tinnitus common among former NFL players with concussion history, study finds
- Is CTE really the main reason behind the rise in NFL player suicides?
- When Tough Isn’t Enough: Why Mental Health in Football Demands Attention
- EXCLUSIVE: New Research Explores Rising Suicide Rates Among Former NFL Players
- ‘They Were All Young’
- What to Know About the Brain Disease CTE
- Assessing Football Players’ Health Beyond Neurodegenerative Disease
- Research Identifies ‘Paradox of Integration’ in NFL
- Study of Former NFL Players Shows Race Differences in Chronic Pain
- Black Former NFL Players More Burdened by Chronic Pain Than White Counterparts, Study Finds
- Racial Differences in Chronic Pain Among Football Players
- NFL Players Age Faster Than the Rest of Us. Harvard is Researching What Can Be Done.
- Football Concussions have a Devastating Sexual Health Outcome
- Podcast: Ricardo Lockette’s mission with Harvard Football Players Health Study
- For NFL Players, Career Length, Role Affect Future Health Risks: Study
- Ex-NFL Players Six Times More Likely Than the General Public to Report Cognitive Problems, Study Finds
- Long NFL Careers Spell Greater Risk for ‘Serious Cognitive Problems,’ Harvard Research Finds
- Erectile Dysfunction Linked to Concussions in NFL Players, Harvard Study Finds
- Former NFL Players with Worse or More Frequent Concussions are More Likely to Show Sexual Dysfunction, Study Shows
- Concussions Linked to Erectile Dysfunction in Former NFL Players
- After Career-ending Injury, ex-Seahawks WR Ricardo Lockette Trying to Keep Current Players Safe
- The N.F.L.’s Obesity Scourge
- Treating Inflammatory Arthritis with Hydrogel
- NFL Doctors Should Not Report to teams, Harvard Study Recommends
- NFL Doctors’ Conflicts of Interest Could Endanger Players, Report Says
- When NFL Calls the Doctor
- Harvard Study on NFL Player Safety Calls for Outside Doctors
- The “I” in TeamStudy
- How to Keep Your Brain Healthy Through Exercise
- Re-growing ACLs? Harvard NFL Study Not Just About Concussions
- Former NFL Players Hope Harvard Study Can Provide Answers to Health Issues
- Ex-NFL Players Use App to Tackle Health Problems
- NFLPA-Affiliated Clinical Study Shows Progress In ACL Tear Treatment
- ACL repair: What It’s Like to be First to Have a New Surgery
- Doctors Experiment With New Way of Fixing the ACL
- A New Procedure Could Revolutionize ACL Repairs
- A Potential Breakthrough in ACL Surgery
- Boston Children’s Hospital Hopes New Procedure Will Revolutionize ACL Treatment
- mHeatlh Intelligence: ResearchKit takes on genetic data, NFL health issues
- App to Tackle Impact of Injuries on NFL Players
- Harvard Launches a New App it Hopes Will Protect NFL Players’ Health
- Can a Sponge Fix Athletes’ Knees?
- Harvard Chan: This week in Health
- Part 1: Harvard study examines long-term effects of playing in NFL
- How will NFL improve concussion problem over the next 50 years?
- Antibody Treatment Could Prevent Alzheimer’s Decline
- Scientists Fix Rogue Protein in Mice that Leads to Alzheimer’s, Brain Damage
- Study: New Antibody Therapy Can Reverse Traumatic Brain Injury Damage (In Mice)
- Great Progress Being Made in Harvard’s Seven NFL Studies
- Let’s Not Kill Football Yet
